We've had Magoo's twice and it's about time I write a review! We are fortunate enough to live close to Lafayette Road / Lafayette Square because that means we have access to some of the best food Indy has to offer! Magoo's California Pizza is definitely a top pick for us!
We ordered the cheesy bread and Chicken Tikka Pizza twice ... and you MUST MUST MUST get the garlic sauce! This is probably the best pizza I have ever had ... the flavors EXPLODE in your mouth and the garlic sauce is just the perfect addition to the pizza. I haven't had chicken tikka with red sauce but given the reviews I saw prior to our first trip there, I had to go with garlic and I'll never change that!