Best Pizza in Eagledale, Indianapolis, IN

Your Neighbourhood Destination For Creative Pizzas Oven Baked To Perfection

Order online

Featured

View menu

We Are Located In Indianapolis – 38th Street

Our 38th Street location at 4919 W 38th St is situated in Georgetown Plaza, along a well-traveled area of Indianapolis. Surrounded by shopping centers, local businesses, and residential neighborhoods, it’s an easy and convenient stop any day of the week. Whether you’re coming from Speedway, Eagle Creek, or nearby west-side neighborhoods, we’re just minutes away.

Find Us!

Crafted For Cravings, Made To Be Remembered

Every bite is layered with bold textures, rich aromas, and perfectly balanced flavors. Made fresh, baked just right, and served with generous portions, our kitchen focuses on quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation—creating comfort that feels indulgent, familiar, and exciting all at once.

Explore Our Menu

Welcome To Magoo’s California Pizza

Address: 4919 W 38th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254, United States Phone: +1 317-293-4411 Hours: Monday: Closed Tuesday: 11 AM – 10 PM Wednesday: 11 AM – 10 PM Thursday: 11 AM – 10 PM Friday: 11 AM – 1 PM, 2:30 PM – 11 PM Saturday: 11 AM – 11 PM Sunday: 11 AM – 10 PM

Get Directions

100% Halal, Always Prepared With Care

We proudly serve food that is 100% halal, prepared with attention to quality, cleanliness, and respect. Every order is thoughtfully made so you can dine with confidence, knowing our standards meet your values—without ever compromising on flavor or experience.

What Our Guests Are Saying

Experience the legendary taste that has made Magoo’s California Pizza a staple on 38th Street. Our guests consistently praise the signature garlic sauce and innovative fusion toppings like Chicken Tikka, noting that the bold, savory profiles are unlike anything else in the city. From the perfectly crispy crust to the generous portions, the sentiment is clear: we provide a unique culinary experience that keeps the community coming back for more. Discover why we're a top-rated Indy destination.

Order From Our Website

Skip the wait and enjoy your favorites from the comfort of home. Our online ordering makes it easy to choose, customize, and enjoy freshly prepared goodness—ready when you are and made with the same care every time.

Order Now

A Closer Look At What We’re Known For

From golden finishes to vibrant layers and irresistible textures, our gallery captures the details that make every order special. Take a scroll, soak in the visuals, and get ready to crave your next bite.

Planning A Gathering Or Special Event?

Let us take care of the food while you enjoy the moment. Whether it’s a casual get-together or a larger celebration, our catering options are designed to serve groups with ease, freshness, and flavors everyone will love—made simple, reliable, and stress-free.

Let Us Cater!

A Place For Everyone

With welcoming vegetarian options, free Wi-Fi, and a kids’ menu for little ones, this is a space made for everyone. Whether you’re dining with family, catching up online, or enjoying a relaxed meal, comfort and convenience come together effortlessly here.

Visit Us Today!! 🍕

Come enjoy a warm, welcoming atmosphere at our 38th Street location in Indianapolis or our Avon spot on E US Hwy 36. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite, a relaxed meal with friends, or a family outing, freshly made favorites, generous flavors, and good vibes are always waiting for you.

What our guests are saying

I don’t know where to start! The staff was super friendly. Whomever was FOH seemed to already know regular customers orders and overall seemed like a community. The food is out of this world. I can look at the pizza and tell how fresh it is. (First time customer) I’ve never had pizza like this before. The brownie is delightful as well. Truly amazing. Will be returning and telling others about Magoos.

Miera T.

We came in right before they closed and ordered 2 pizzas. The supreme pizza was as the name implies. SUPREME. The pizza was really tasty, and well worth the money. If I had to say so myself I'd say their claim of best pizza in Indiana definitely fits. You guys are awesome and I will be returning often for more pizza. Thank you guys for the service that you provide! What a great find.

Mr. K.

I love this place! I’ve been coming here for years. They give great energy, great vibes, and great food. I haven’t experienced any trouble with the restaurant; they provide exceptional service and quality food. My kids love it! They carry conversations and greet you by name! It feels good to be greeted by name, means the business values us.